Sign up with your email address to be the first to know about new products, VIP offers, blog features & more.

Why the Job Market Isn’t as Closed as You Think

Don’t believe the hype

The Competition Isn’t What You Think It Is

Whether you were just laid off or you’re still employed but reading the writing on the wall, the instinct is the same: why look now? There are no jobs.

That fear is legitimate. The market is genuinely harder than it was two years ago.

But ‘harder’ isn’t the same as ‘closed’. And the math inside a hiring process tells a very different story than the one in your news feed.

I’ve had this conversation across industries, disciplines, and experience levels. I’ve had it with people who should absolutely know better — recruiters included. Yes, recruiter roles are down. There is also still turnover, retirements among Boomers, and medical leave. The market is not a closed door. It’s a narrower one.

But let’s talk about the real math, because it changes everything.

When a company posts a role and gets 100-300 applications, that number feels like a wall. Most people look at the numbers and think: Why bother?

Here’s the question nobody asks: of those applicants, how many are actually qualified?

In my experience, somewhere between 8 and 10.

Not because the other 190 are bad people. Because a significant number of applicants removed themselves from consideration before anyone read a single line.

They didn’t read the posting.

They saw a title that sounded close enough and hit apply. I’ve posted customer service roles where we were very specific — technical calls, longer handle times, tech industry experience required. We still get flooded with applications from high-volume call center backgrounds with zero technical experience. They applied to the job title, not to the job.

They submitted typos

  • A resume or online application with errors gets declined before anyone picks up a phone. That alone removes 5-10+% of the stack without a conversation.
  • Blank fields or incomplete information on the application will slow down momentum

They were overqualified by a wide margin

Not one or two years — five or ten. This feels like a safe bet for the candidate. It isn’t. A hiring manager isn’t excited about paying a senior-level salary for a junior-level role, and they’re already calculating how long it will be before that person leaves for something better matched. Overqualified isn’t flattering. It’s a retention problem before the person starts.

They applied from the wrong location

Companies require in-office or hybrid attendance, yet many candidates still apply, assuming the rules will be more flexible for them. That occasionally works at very senior levels for very specialized skills. For most postings, the hiring manager sees the wrong city and moves on. The location requirement often came from above their pay grade. They don’t have the authority to bend it even if they wanted to. The filter happens at the location field, not the qualifications section.

So the real competition isn’t 300 people.

It’s 8.

And of those 8, the company realistically moves forward with 2-3 for final interviews.

There’s another group worth mentioning

Some candidates don’t apply because they feel like they don’t check every box. In my experience, these are usually the people who did read the posting — and are often closer to qualified than they think. Job descriptions are wish lists, not contracts. The person who hits 7 of 10 requirements and can articulate why they’re the right hire will beat the person who claims all 10 and can’t back any of them up.

The people opting out are often more competitive than they realize.

So what’s the actual advice?

Don’t look at the 200. Look at the 8.

Apply selectively.

Read the full posting before you apply — actually read it. Make sure the role, company size, culture, and requirements are a real match for what you bring. Tailor the resume to reflect that match specifically. No typos.

That’s it. You don’t have to be exceptional. You just have to clear a bar that most applicants are voluntarily stepping over.

The market is noisier than it used to be. It is not as closed as people are leading themselves to believe. And the people sitting on the sidelines, waiting for better news, are handing over a smaller and smaller pool to everyone who decides to move anyway.

 

See you at the after party,

Ringo “HRNasty” Nishioka

nasty: an unreal maneuver of incredible technique, something that is ridiculously good, tricky, and manipulative but with a result that can’t help but be admired, a phrase used to describe someone good at something. “He has a nasty forkball”.

 

For deeper dives into your Career Reality, see the catalog of books and survival guides.

Did this article change how you see career decisions? Get Career Reality Updates from the other side of the management table.

Ringo Nishioka writes about how managers actually make career decisions. Follow on LinkedIn and Bluesky.

 

No Comments Yet.

What do you think?